Home » Columns »Sustainable Planet » Currently Reading:

The Last Deglacial Transition

March 21, 2012 by Tony Noerpel filed under Columns, Sustainable Planet No Comments
noerpel150

“Although the current overall capacity for society to perturb the carbon cycle is comparable to that of the PETM [the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum, 55 million years ago], the rate at which we are imposing the current perturbation on the Earth system may be unprecedented.” Ying Cui et al. [1]

“The last deglacial transition, although characterized by temperature and CO2-increase, is two orders of magnitude slower than the current anthropogenic change. It is also thought to largely represent a redistribution of carbon within the ocean and to the atmosphere and terrestrial biosphere and hence did not have as potent or globally uniform an acidification effect as an input from geological reserves.” B. Honisch et al [2].

At a party a few weeks ago a friend identified himself as a moderate claiming to listen to both sides of arguments. I suggested that an issue like illegal immigration has no basis in the hard sciences and therefore on that issue at least a moderate view might make sense but that opinions on either side are likely ideological. I suppose there is a body of historic data or economic analysis but these are subject to cherry picking. Economic analysis is famous for being capable of deriving any desired result and history is a soft science. But the issue of anthropogenic global warming is different. Global warming is founded on hard science by experimentation, observation and analysis and has been developed using the scientific method and is therefore quite rigorous. Thus the truth is knowable with reasonably good approximation. I reminded my friend of Nobel Laureate Physicist Richard Feynman’s advice that science is what humans do to keep from lying to ourselves.

To deny global warming is to deny science itself and thus reality and consequently to slide down a slippery slope into a mind space where any inconvenient reality can be denied and all self-deception can be rationalized. Since AGW is an existential issue for the human race denial is a rather big lie and one cannot reasonably assume a denier isn’t also lying about everything else. And reality has to inform the moderate view else it isn’t moderate.

My friend said [3] “Wait a minute, Tony, there are compelling arguments. After all, the climate has changed in the past without human influence. Consider the ice ages.”

Like all denier arguments, this one is curiously nonsensical. This is easy to appreciate by using the same argument in a different the context. A cigarette smoker informs you that there is no reason for him not to smoke in bed because houses burn down from natural causes. Sure they do but the number one cause of fatal fires is still careless smoking [4]. The possibility of one does not rule out the possibility of the other. In fact, the study of natural house fires reveals just how flammable houses are and how sensitive they are to careless smoking and other human misbehavior. Another salient point is that the scientists, who study one cause, are the same ones who study the other. It is not the case that deniers study natural causes and climate scientists study only human causes. Climate scientists study both while deniers simply make stuff up.

I replied, “Seriously, John? That argument doesn’t make any sense even if you don’t know the science. But the science is that the transition from the depths of the ice age with ice a mile deep over New York to the mild Holocene when humans discovered agriculture and built cities was two orders of magnitude slower than what humans are doing to the climate now; two orders of magnitude slower.”

He looked back at me stunned so I repeated, filling the void, “Two orders of magnitude slower and yet the impact was that dramatic. Did your source forget to mention that not insignificant detail?”

The figure below is from a recent paper by Andrea Burke and Laura Robinson published in the journal Science [5]. The purple curve is a reconstruction of atmospheric carbon dioxide from ice core data stretching back from the last glacial maximum (LGM), 20,000 years ago through the Holocene to the pre-industrial era. I superimposed a box circumscribing the part of the curve which shows the fastest rise in atmospheric carbon dioxide during this time. Atmospheric carbon dioxide increased 30 parts per million by Volume (ppmV) from 17,300 years ago until 16,000 years ago or over a period of 1300 years at the beginning of the shaded Heinrich stadial 1 (HS1). This is equivalent to an average rise of 0.023 ppmV/year over the period of fastest increase. The increase during the Younger Dryas (YD) is almost as steep. Currently, human emissions are increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide by about 2.4 ppmV or one hundred times faster than the most rapid increase during the last deglaciation.


Figure is adapted from Andrea Burke and Laura Robinson [5]. The purple curve is the Atmospheric carbon measurements from arctic ice core records

Likewise the global temperature increased about 5 degree Celsius over thousands of years or by the same amount as the projections based on a business-as-usual path for human emissions for just this century [6]. I wanted to ask my friend who he thought was studying paleoclimate if not actual credible climate scientists. Did he think deniers were generating this science? In fact the study of past climate change, paleoclimatology, is of great interest to climate scientists who are desperately looking for analogous events to the current situation. This study will be a significant part of the next Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report [7].

A good recent example is a paper by Barbel Honisch and colleagues [2] which reviews climate change events of the past 300 million years and concludes that “Although similarities exist, no past event perfectly parallels future projections in terms of disrupting the balance of ocean carbonate chemistry – a consequence of the unprecedented rapidity of CO2 release currently taking place.” In fact the Permian Triassic extinction event, 252 million years ago may be the closest analogue but it was accompanied by an estimated annual carbon release of between 0.1 and 1 Gigatons per year compared with current human emissions which are 10 Gigatons per year. Yet the End Permian was the most severe of all mass extinction events, extirpating between 90 and 96 percent of all species [8]. We are emitting carbon ten times faster and combining that with a large variety of additional coherent misbehavior such as over fishing, mountaintop removal mining and over fertilization.

Meanwhile about global warming Senator Inhofe said on MSNBC last week in an interview with Rachel Maddow [9]: “I was actually on your side of this issue when I was chairing that committee and I first heard about this. I thought it must be true until I found out what it cost.” In other words, Inhofe decided to deny physical reality because it conflicted with his very bad economics. Demonstrating that he has gone well off the deep end, Inhofe has also said [10]: “The arrogance of people to think that we, human beings, would be able to change what He is doing in the climate is to me outrageous.” Obviously only God can change the climate and start house fires. So according to Inhofe we are all off the hook; liars, murderers, rapists, careless smokers, strip miners, coal companies, Wall Street bankers, corrupt senators, everybody because only God can do anything and if you think your activity has any significance at all, you are just too bloody arrogant. Some theology.

I find it curious that my friend, who is intelligent, would be skeptical of legitimate science while accepting unquestioningly utter nonsense from utterly unreliable people (I assume his source is the main-stream media). Why Inhofe rejects science in favor of nonsense is not nearly as mysterious when we consider that he has received over $1.3 million in campaign contributions from the fossil fuels industry [11]. Money talks and only God can take a bribe.

I’ve pointed out before that the Republican Party institutionally denies climate physics and therefore cannot be trusted on any issue, but heck don’t take my word for it. Ann Coulter [12] recently said: “I think our party and particularly our movement, the conservative movement, does have more of a problem with con men and charlatans than the Democratic Party.” Dishonesty attracts them like flies.

Dear reader, the climate has indeed changed in the past in ways which have been quite dramatic and on a few occasions even resulting in mass extinctions. And yet the perturbations to the earth system, the forcing functions, have been one or more orders of magnitude slower than what we are doing now in many respects but we are also doing additional things which are unprecedented. What do you think the outcome is going to be? You may want to ask yourselves while looking at your kids and grandkids if Homo sapiens could survive a major mass extinction event, regardless of whether it was caused by God or by our own misbehavior.

And a moderate does not take counsel from con men and charlatans.

[1] Ying Cui, Lee R. Kump, Andy J. Ridgwell, Adam J. Charles, Christopher K. Junium, Aaron F. Diefendorf, Katherine H. Freeman, Nathan M. Urban and Ian C. Harding, Slow release of fossil carbon during the Palaeocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum, Nature Geoscience, 5 June 2011 | DOI: 10.1038/NGEO1179

[2] B. Honisch, et al., The Geological Record of Ocean Acidification, Science, vol 335, 2 March, 2012.

[3] It would not have mattered if my friend had chosen any other denier argument as they are all pretty ludicrous. For a complete list with applicable debunking see http://www.skepticalscience.com/

[4] http://www.usfa.fema.gov/downloads/pdf/statistics/urban.pdf

[5] Andrea Burke and Laura Robinson, The Southern Ocean’s Role in Carbon Exchange During the Last Deglaciation, Science, vol 335, 3 February 2012. See also Michael Kaplan, et al., Glacier retreat in New Zealand during the Younger Dryas stadial, Vol 467| 9 September 2010| doi:10.1038/nature09313

[6] James E. Hansen and Makiko Sato, Paleoclimate Implications for Human-Made Climate Change, NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies and Columbia University Earth Institute, New York. See also the MIT study Sokolov, A. P., and Coauthors, 2009: Probabilistic Forecast for Twenty-First-Century Climate Based on Uncertainties in Emissions (Without Policy) and Climate Parameters. J. Climate, 22, 5175–5204. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1175/2009JCLI2863.1 see also http://globalchange.mit.edu/pubs/abstract.php?publication_id=990

[7] J. Tollefson, “Forecasters look back in time”, Nature, vol 483, 15 March, 2012, also P. Valdes, Built for Stability, Nature Geoscience, vol 4, July 2011, and R. Zeebe, Where are you heading Earth?, in the same issue.

[8] Michael Benton, When Life Nearly Died, Thames and Hudson 2003, also Douglas Erwin, Extinction, Princeton, 2006.

[9] http://thinkprogress.org/romm/2012/03/16/446008/inhofe-maddow-global-warming/

[10] http://thinkprogress.org/romm/2012/03/12/442584/inhofe-arrogance-people-change-god-climate/

[11] http://www.opensecrets.org/politicians/summary.php?cycle=Career&type=I&cid=N00005582&newMem=N

[12] http://thinkprogress.org/romm/2012/03/15/445436/ann-coulter-gop-conservative-movement-has-problem-with-con-men-and-charlatans/

Comment on this article


By commenting, you agree to abide by our Terms of Service.


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Columns

A Habitable Planet

noerpel_new

“At the moments when we are able to separate ourselves from our daily concerns and ponder deeply, most of us have encountered fundamental questions of our existence as human beings. Where do we come from? What happened before humans appeared …

Choose Joy, Don’t Go Negative

Lunde new

Sometimes life is pleasant and it is easy to smile, other times it is not. The real question is how do you react and live your life when you are going through trials? What do you do when you feel …

Character Outlives Us All

moore-sobelnewmug

“Brains are like muscles, you can rent them by the hour, but at the end of the day all you have left is your character.” This statement was uttered by Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, a phrase his father used …

Foxridge Park

Just Like Nothing (Else) On Earth- Foxridge Park-1

You know, I can still taste those sausages: The first early-spring bratwurst cooked over an open flame in a beautiful setting among good friends; nothing so surprising, really, in recalling a good meal in classic context. The thing is, though …

Planning for Life Disclosure and Other Family Issues in Estate Planning

Smith0035

What do we tell the kids? Questions of how much and what type of information to give the children often arise during consultation. The answers depend on the circumstances of each family – the ages and maturity of the children …

A Look Into What Is Learned in High School English

Lunde new

By Mary Rose Lunde English is the arguably the most important subject for a student in high school to learn. The most successful people in the world have one thing in common — being able to communicate effectively. This is …

Editorial

Grief and Greed

blueridge2

By Matthew Parse What would drive a single individual to cause so much emotional stress and financial burden on hundreds, if not, thousands of families? What would drive the Town …

Op-ed

Oh No, It’s the Christians!

blueridge2

By Nicholas Reid In the hours and days following every massacre perpetrated by radical Muslims, there is one unifying theme across most news coverage of the massacre, wherever it may …

Dear Editor

Isn’t Loudoun Better Than This?

blueridge2

More than forty years I have watched a rising tide of development flowing from the east across Loudoun. Once it was thought the western mountains would be spared the flood. …

View From the Ridge

An Open Letter to the Citizens of Purcellville

blueridge2

Mark Your Calendar, They’ve Asked for Our Input So Let’s Give It To Them By Steady and Nobull The Purcellville Planning Commission has tentatively scheduled a series of public input …

Student News

Four Scouts Achieve Eagle Scout Rank

3 Feb 2016

eaglescout

Joel Gicker, Kyle Siecker, Sam Soltis and David Watson achieved the rank of Eagle Scout at a Court of Honor conducted at Blue Ridge Bible Church in Purcellville on January 9. The four Eagles are members of Troop 711 of …

(Be the first to comment)

8th Grade Writers Honored At Blue Ridge Middle School

2 Jul 2015

blueridgemiddleschool

Sixty-seven Blue Ridge Middle School eighth graders have been honored for their writing during the 2014-2015 school year. Many students had their writing selected for publication by Creative Communication, a program for student writers, while others won county-wide writing contests. …

(Be the first to comment)

Ben Kellogg Achieves Eagle Scout

1 Jul 2015

benkellog

Benjamin Robert Kellogg achieved the rank of Eagle Scout at a Court of Honor conducted at St. Andrew’s Presbyterian Church in Purcellville on March 29. Friends, family and troop leaders attended the celebration, including his parents, Robert and Deirdre Kellogg. …

(Be the first to comment)

Calendar

May 2016
M T W T F S S
25 26 27

Hamilton Town Hall

28 29

CHITTY CHITTY BANG BANG at Franklin Park Arts Center

30

Lobster Day with Chef Seb at North Gate Vineyard

CHITTY CHITTY BANG BANG at Franklin Park Arts Center

1

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

Spring Wine Glass Painting with Penny

2

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

3

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

4

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

5

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

6

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

TGIF @ North Gate Vineyard!

7

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

The Sprouted Spoon Food Truck at North Gate Vineyard

Nathaniel Davis Live at North Gate Vineyard

Notaviva Vineyards - Bluegrass Jam - FREE event

8

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

Celebrate Mother's Day at North Gate Vineyard!

Mother's Day Brunch at Breaux

9

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

10

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

11

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

12

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

13

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

14

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

Dog Day at Breaux Vineyards

15

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

16

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

17

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

18

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

19

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

Senior Caregiver Training

Hillsboro Ruritan Club Dinner Meeting

20

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

Strawberry Afternoon Tea

21

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

Strawberry Afternoon Tea

22

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

Land Trust of Virginia Annual Garden Party

BRASS EXTRAVAGANZA

Waterford Concert

23

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

24

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

25

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

26

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

27

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

28

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

A Taste of Paris and View of Normandy at Breaux Vineyards

Annie Stokes Live at North Gate Vineyard

29

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

Paella by Carlos at North Gate Vineyard

30

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

31

Sea & Sky – an exhibit by copper artist Anne Jordan and mixed media artist Karen Watson

1

It’s a Beach Thing . . . featuring lamp-work glass artist Julie Bahun and abstract painter Karen Hutchison

2

It’s a Beach Thing . . . featuring lamp-work glass artist Julie Bahun and abstract painter Karen Hutchison

Free Gardening Lecture

3

It’s a Beach Thing . . . featuring lamp-work glass artist Julie Bahun and abstract painter Karen Hutchison

4

It’s a Beach Thing . . . featuring lamp-work glass artist Julie Bahun and abstract painter Karen Hutchison

Yard Sale

Notaviva Vineyards - Bluegrass Jam - FREE event

PAUL REISLER TRIO WITH LEA MORRIS AND MARSHALL KEYS

5

It’s a Beach Thing . . . featuring lamp-work glass artist Julie Bahun and abstract painter Karen Hutchison

Current Print Issue:
Sign up for our email newsletter:

Recent Comments

Lifestyle

New Concert Series Comes to Purcellville

20 May 2016

brianganz150

On Sunday, June 5 at 4:00 p.m., internationally recognized pianist Brian Ganz will present an all-Chopin recital at St. Andrew Presbyterian Church, 711 W. Main Street in Purcellville. The recital will feature several of Frédéric Chopin’s studies for solo piano, including the renowned “Revolutionary” Etude, among other works by the Romantic master. Ganz, who recently moved to Purcellville from Annapolis, …

(Be the first to comment)

Eucharistic Procession To Pass Through Leesburg May 29

20 May 2016

Eucharist

– By Mark Gunderman Each year, Catholics around the world celebrate the Feast of Corpus Christi (Latin for Body of Christ), symbolizing their belief in the Real Presence of Jesus Christ in the Eucharist. In the United States, the celebration of Corpus Christi is held on the Sunday after Trinity Sunday. This is a time when Catholics can demonstrate their …

(Be the first to comment)

Art in the Burg, Middleburg’s Town-Wide Arts Celebration

12 May 2016

middleburg_seal

Sponsored by the Middleburg Arts Council and the Town of Middleburg On Saturday, May 21, the Middleburg Arts Council and the Town of Middleburg will host the fourth town-wide arts celebration, Art in the Burg. Artwork from more than 20 local and regional artists of different styles, forms and subject matter will be on display at 108 East Washington Street, …

(Be the first to comment)

Around Virginia

Out and About Loudoun and Beyond

The Plains’ charming restaurants, shops and sidewalks.

Five Stone’s Throw Spring and Summer Destinations By Andrea Gaines Bordered by the Potomac River to the north and beautiful mountains to the west – and with easy access to Rt. 95, the Dulles Toll Road and Route 66 – Loudouners have no short list of fun spring places to …

(Be the first to comment)

Update: Remains Located in Shenandoah National Park; Search Efforts Suspended

VSP Photo - 4-21-16 Whiteoak Canyon Trail Entrance VSP

Update: Body preliminarily identified as Nicole K. Mittendorff, 31, of Woodbridge. The physical and digital evidence collected during the course of this investigation includes a note recovered from the car leads investigators to believe there was no foul play involved in her death. ——————– Search efforts in the Shenandoah National …

(Be the first to comment)

Virginia Trooper Shot and Killed at Richmond Bus Terminal

Tpr Dermyer Patrol Car in front of VSP SPHQ

A Virginia State Police trooper has died as a result of his injuries after being shot on March 31 at the Greyhound Bus station in the 2900 block of North Boulevard in Richmond. At approximately 2:40 p.m., Virginia State Police Trooper Chad P. Dermyer approached a male subject just inside …

(Be the first to comment)

Sports

Western Loudon Volleyball Club “Hitmen” Team Finishes Second

3 Feb 2016

westernloudounvolleyballclub

The Western Loudon Volleyball Club U14 boys team, called the “Hitmen,” finished second in a tournament held January 17. This is the first ever boys team for the WLVBC (and only the second boys club in the area). Coach Allan Kotmel led the seven-member team. WLVBC started eight years ago, …

(Be the first to comment)

ODFC West Travel Soccer Program Shines

2 Dec 2015

ODFCsoccerpics

The Old Dominion Football Club West boys and girls middle school travel soccer program scored big the weekend of November 21 and 22.  The girls Quest Premier 22 team took home the championship in the U12 Girls Premier Division of the Hunt Country Classic located in Fauquier County. The boys …

(Be the first to comment)

Archives

  • +2016
  • +2015
  • +2014
  • +2013
  • +2012
  • +2011
  • +2010
  • +2009